The Nagara-Kertagama of Winada-Prapanca: a panegyric on Hayan Wuruk of Majapahit


No kidding.  And did Felipe Fernández-Armesto really read it, or did someone just tell him about it?  You’re bound to ask that kind of question of an author who drops so many names.


Civilizations has been my bedtime book for weeks, and I’ve been falling asleep with suspicious promptitude most nights.  It ought to be very interesting:  an attempt to group and analyse human cultures by the natural environment in which they developed, and by the extent to which they modified nature.  There are peoples and cities here of which I have never even heard.  But because each culture receives so little space, it’s like having someone read you a list – and only Spike Milligan could get away with that (anyone else remember the Directory of Huntingdonshire Cabmen?)

It might be the comatose state in which I read it, but I don’t really know if the book has an argument or a unifying thesis; it all seemed a bit muddled.  Maybe there is one in the final chapter, but I ditched on page 491.  The jig was up on page 339 anyway.  In the section on Easter Island, Fernández-Armesto writes of ‘… proud monoliths, left to collapse in indignity and lie in neglect …  the undecipherable inscriptions, howling inarticulately from the faces of the tablets …’.  I tried to overlook it, but it was no good.  The posy style was already annoying me, and I’m not about to forgive anyone for howling inscriptions.

8 responses »

  1. And inarticulately howling inscriptions, no less. I feel your pain, as somebody or other said – I’ve spent too much money over the years on books that gave me meaningless snippets on complex, interesting topics. (On the other hand, I’m very fond of Mithen’s “After the Ice” – a worldwide survey of what archaeology can tell us about people between the end of the last ice age and the invention of civilization – even though it’s definitely a bedtime, or bathroom 😉 , book.)

  2. Ah yes, I remember the Huntingdonshire Cabmen well. But you still got to page 391 even while it was sleep-inducing. That’s some kind of impressive.
    ps. Meant to say something about the ‘Dover Beach’ allusion the other day; I presume you also know Anthony Hecht’s ‘The Dover Bitch?’

    • I hate to be beaten. And it was quite useful as a soporific – if it’s too interesting a book, I’m still flipping the pages at 2 am, which isn’t good for me the next day.

Leave a Reply to rthepotter Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s